Political Crossfire Forums

This is ridiculous.

What is making this person live in a cell for 35 years going to accomplish?

You're a bigot with a shallow and inaccurate view of transgendered people. That's about all anyone can take away from your awful post.

Has Manning actually said that thats his reason for leaking the stuff?

live boy or dead girl.


/just sayin'

I'm not surprised either. Actually Manning, Snowden, and Assange all wanted to be women. Their grand plan is to leak US secrets, become women and live happily as lesbians.

The government wants to get all up in everyone's business, but they don't want anyone knowing what they do.

lol

What I heard is that he will get out in 8 years and he will still be only 33. Good for him... her?

It's amazing what we've learned about what our gov't really does thanks to people like Manning and now Snowden. Who would've thunk that when it came to assaulting the privacies/liberties of Americans, Obama was taking his cues from Dick Cheney?

My post is only relating to "imprisoned transgender people". Please don't view it as any indictment or opinion on those outside of prison. If you are outside, your business is your business - frankly, I don't think about it much.

Manning has said that he thinks he was born a woman, and wants to undergo a surgical transformation. He was born a woman and is trapped in a man's body. I can understand that sentiment. But, is it really something that the state should pay for?

Is it really any more different than me saying that "I was born a good looking man, with a full head of hair, but I'm stuck in body of a slightly overweight guy with male-patterned-baldness"? Therefore, if I were imprisoned, the state should pay for hair transplant surgery, plastic surgery, and liposuction.

I realize, of course, that there is a major difference in scale. Being stuck in another gender's body is more serious than being stuck in a body that doesn't look as good as it could. But, it's only a matter of degree. Where is the line drawn? Is the line at "sex change"? What about "sex modification" (enlargement, reduction, addition, subtraction, etc.)?

Basically, I'm saying that he should continue to be a man unless and until he can pay for the surgery himself. If he can pay for it while at Leavenworth, great. if not, he waits.