Also Dungy wasn't the best big game coach in the world.. And those Colts teams also lacked toughness. Teams with an attitude like the Ravens or Steelers would smack them around and the Colts would roll over.. That's not the QB's fault, that's the team fault.
I guess the best example to use to prove Manning's worth to the Colts was how many years in a row did they make the playoffs with Manning as QB? 12? Then he sits out 2011 and the Colts go 2-14.. That says it all..